Unlock the Editor’s Digest free of charge
Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favorite tales on this weekly e-newsletter.
European Fee president Ursula von der Leyen is dealing with a no-confidence vote over a Covid-19 pandemic scandal that threatens to scupper her second-term coverage agenda.
Far-right lawmakers within the European parliament declare they’ve secured enough help for his or her movement demanding the fee’s resignation after an EU courtroom dominated towards her dealing with of personal messages with the CEO of a prescribed drugs firm.
Whereas von der Leyen is more likely to survive the vote, which may happen subsequent month, it might power her to make extra compromises each to the left and the best to safe their help.
Romanian far-right MEP Gheorghe Piperea instructed the Monetary Occasions he would desk the movement on Thursday after gathering greater than the required 72 signatures.
“The initiative is basically about upholding transparency and making certain a good and real democratic course of,” he mentioned.
Whereas the brink for triggering a no-confidence vote is low, toppling von der Leyen and her fee would require greater than two-thirds of MEPs in attendance. The meeting counts 720 members and 401 voted for her to turn into president a 12 months in the past, although she has alienated some since.
Piperea claimed some members of her personal centre-right European Individuals’s occasion (EPP) have been backing his initiative. He acknowledged nevertheless that the probabilities for it to succeed have been slim, however mentioned it supplied a “essential alternative for constructive and substantiated criticism in direction of president Ursula von der Leyen.
“It obliges the fee to handle considerations and supply justifications.”
No-confidence votes are uncommon, however can have severe penalties. In 1999 Jacques Santer’s staff resigned over fraud allegations and lack of transparency even after profitable a vote of confidence. There have been simply 4 since, none of them profitable.
The Piperea movement is predicated on the so-called Pfizergate courtroom case towards von der Leyen but additionally criticises her remedy of parliament, a criticism shared by centrists and leftwing MEPs, who allege she typically bypasses the bloc’s solely immediately elected establishment and is simply too accommodating to EU governments.
The EU’s basic courtroom in Could dominated towards the fee in a battle over the publication of textual content messages between von der Leyen and Pfizer’s chief government Albert Bourla throughout negotiations to provide Covid vaccines in 2021.
The New York Occasions introduced the case after von der Leyen’s staff refused to reveal the messages. The courtroom rejected the fee’s argument that it couldn’t discover them and had “breached the precept of fine administration”.
“The courtroom discovered the fee’s refusal legally unsound and missing credible justification,” Piperea mentioned. “These actions display a continued sample of institutional over-reach, democratic disregard, and erosion of public belief within the Union’s governance.”
Progressive MEPs opened up a recent entrance final week when the fee mentioned it supposed to withdraw a regulation banning so-called greenwashing — unfounded environmental claims by corporations — simply days earlier than parliament and member states have been aiming to achieve a ultimate settlement on it.
The regulation has turn into the newest lightning rod for anti-green sentiment within the bloc pushed by von der Leyen’s personal centre-right political group.
The Socialists, who’re the second greatest faction in parliament, and liberal Renew, who’re fifth, wrote a joint letter on Wednesday to parliament president Roberta Metsola asking her to boost the matter with von der Leyen and EU leaders at a summit on Thursday.
Parliament, they argue, wants “to be correctly consulted consistent with the precept of honest co-operation” each time a regulation is axed. “We additionally contemplate that the accountable commissioners must be summoned to the respective committees to clarify their intentions.”
The Greens, who backed von der Leyen, have additionally attacked the transfer.
Some EU capitals have additionally expressed dissent, arguing that the last-minute withdrawal undermines the credibility of EU lawmaking, based on diplomats near the talks.
Teresa Ribera, fee vice-president overseeing inexperienced points, instructed the FT: “I hope that these messy days might be clarified as quickly as potential and that we will attain a consensus.”
Individually, members of its authorized committee on Wednesday voted to ask Metsola to sue the fee as a result of it eluded parliament when it determined to situation extra debt to gas the bloc’s rearmament drive.
Piperea’s movement additionally mentions this alleged “procedural abuse”. He “calls on the European Fee to resign because of repeated failures to make sure transparency, persistent disregard for democratic oversight and the rule of regulation inside the Union”.
A spokesperson for the parliament declined to remark.
Further reporting by Barbara Moens in Brussels
