Bose Extremely Earbuds 2nd Gen evaluation: chunky design, unbelievable ANC

Bose has constructed its fashionable status on noise-canceling efficiency, providing the perfect in school for an excellent twenty years, because the launch of the QuietComfort headphones in 2000. However Sony and Apple caught up in 2023 and the race has gone forwards and backwards since. The $299 Bose QuietComfort Extremely second-gen earbuds intention to high the competitors once more, and this time with enhancements to sound and name high quality, each of which have been points for the QC earbuds prior to now.

Whereas the hole between “nice” and “the perfect” noise canceling has been narrowing with every new earbuds iteration, Bose has by some means continued to enhance. The noise canceling of the second-gen Extremely Earbuds is phenomenal. Its attenuation of low-frequency sounds specifically nearly eliminates the distraction of airplane engines, particularly with the addition of music or dialogue from a film.

The noise canceling additionally takes the sting off of loud conversations in a restaurant or on the road. It doesn’t utterly take away the chatter round you (and no noise-canceling earbuds do), but it surely considerably reduces the sound. And in contrast to the AirPods Professional 3, the Bose ANC doesn’t have a higher-end hiss. The excessive stage of noise canceling may cause the Bose to really feel virtually disconcertingly isolating, however is spectacular nonetheless.

If the very best stage of noise canceling appears like an excessive amount of, the Bose app permits for adjustment to the depth — a management absent from AirPods — with 11 steps, together with full on and full off. You’ll must create a customized listening mode to have adjustable ANC, because the included presets (Quiet, Conscious, Immersion, and Cinema) have that choice locked, however when you do you’ll be able to regulate to style. Including a preset is straightforward. Simply hit the “+” button within the Modes menu, choose from 10 totally different names — together with Commute, Music, and Run — and regulate the noise canceling depth and Immersive Audio setting. The settings you select aren’t locked in and will be modified as essential.

Bose has improved the way in which the QuietComfort Extremely 2nd Gen deal with transparency mode, or Conscious mode, because it’s referred to as within the app. On most earbuds, together with earlier QuietComfort fashions, transparency mode allows all of the sound round you, making it seem to be you don’t have the earbuds in, so you’ll be able to hear your environment and maintain conversations. The second-gen Extremely, although, nonetheless tamp down low-end frequencies whereas in Conscious mode, which permits your ear to raised give attention to voices. Listening to a barista’s questions as I order my espresso is less complicated as a result of the thump of the background music isn’t as current.

In earlier Bose earbuds, I’ve discovered name high quality to be subpar, scuffling with even gentle breezes. Whereas testing the QuietComfort Earbuds II a couple of years in the past, a automotive alarm a block and a half away brought on the individual on the opposite finish of my name to shriek in agony. The second-gen Extremely don’t have these points, although because the Bose adjusts to outdoors noises, it impacts my vocal high quality a bit, so my voice isn’t pristine and clear. The ANC was in a position to block most of an exceptionally loud sports activities automotive that revved its engines because it handed, although it brought on a little bit of compression that sounded unnatural, in accordance with an audio trade buddy on the opposite aspect of my name. And after I listened again to a recording I made outdoors, I might hear the compression including a raspy high quality to my voice. That raspiness wasn’t current in a recording made inside my residence the place the noise suppression wasn’t wanted.

Whereas the second-gen Extremely don’t compete with Apple or Sony for name high quality, they carry out in addition to they should. “The earbuds allow you to sound such as you,” my audio trade buddy commented throughout a name. He might inform from the compression whether or not I used to be outdoors or inside, but it surely wasn’t a distracting sufficient change to drag him out of the dialog.

When taking part in music, the second-gen Extremely sound just like the previous few iterations of Bose earbuds. The bass is a bit heavy, and better frequencies are overemphasized with sure tracks. “Tremendous Bon Bon” from Soul Coughing’s Irresistible Bliss consists of a lot of metallic, industrial sounds to assist construct the track all through, which might get fatiguing at increased volumes. Nonetheless, there’s nothing in regards to the Bose sound that’s dangerous, and the vast majority of individuals are certain to get pleasure from it.

There are EQ controls within the app, however they’re not that useful, solely permitting 3-band changes to bass, mid, and treble. Bringing the treble down whereas listening to the Soul Coughing monitor barely tamed the excessive finish, but it surely additionally eliminated among the life from the track.

There’s an Immersive Audio choice within the app designed to “improve and add depth to your content material.” Like Apple Spatial Audio, there’s a digital speaker positioning that may comply with your head positioning, so the entrance of the soundstage is at all times the course you’re going through, as with common audio alerts, however with a bit extra digital depth. It will also be static. In that case, turning to your left would transfer the middle of the soundstage into your proper ear, as would occur if you happen to had been listening to a band at a membership and turned to speak to your buddy. In both mode, there’s an added depth to the entrance, however not a lot past that. I most well-liked it off.

Bose’s earbud design has hardly modified because the QuietComfort Earbuds II in 2022, and that’s their largest disadvantage. The QuietComfort Extremely Earbuds 2nd Gen case now helps wi-fi charging, which is a welcome addition, however past that, there’s not numerous distinction. The case is about three quarters of an inch taller than the AirPods Professional 3 case and simply over an inch taller than the Sony WF-1000XM5 case.

The earbuds’ bulbous our bodies prolong out of the ears and don’t look or really feel as modern as their rivals. The general form makes dealing with them clunky. Even getting a grip to take away them from the charging case will be troublesome — a difficulty I’ve had with the design because it was launched. The broad capacitive floor for contact controls is liable to inadvertent faucets as you reposition. The contact controls will be disabled within the app, however that additionally removes the comfort.

The buds include three suggestions and three wings to customise the match, and so they stayed safe in my ears all through testing. They will really feel a bit uncomfortable after a couple of hours, however with a battery life that tops out at six hours — which is simply common — lengthy listening classes would require a cost, permitting your ears to get a brief relaxation. A 20-minute fast cost will get you two hours of listening, whereas totally charging the battery takes two hours. (The case, which now has wi-fi charging functionality, holds sufficient cost for as much as 18 extra hours of listening, for twenty-four hours complete.) They’re not exercise earbuds; they’ve an IPX4 ranking, which is safety from splashing, so be cautious utilizing them for greater than gentle train. (The case isn’t rated in any respect.)

Even with out drastic design modifications, the improved noise canceling and conscious mode efficiency, higher name high quality, and addition of wi-fi case charging maintain the Bose QuietComfort Extremely Earbuds 2nd Gen within the dialogue as the most effective pairs of noise-canceling earbuds. I’d even put them above the AirPods Professional 3 when it comes strictly to ANC efficiency (the AirPods are nonetheless all-around higher, particularly for Apple customers). Do I want Bose had up to date the design to be smaller and simpler to deal with, with higher battery life? Completely. However till then, the Extremely 2nd Gen earbuds are a wonderful alternative for non-Apple customers, frequent flyers, or anybody on the lookout for a break from our busy, noisy world.

Images by John Higgins / The Verge