A recent sketch on the popular American television show “Saturday Night Live” has garnered significant attention for its satirical portrayal of a widespread societal phenomenon: the disproportionate burden of elder care often shouldered by daughters rather than sons. The comedic advertisement, featuring actor John Mulaney, humorously highlighted the unpaid, 24/7 care provided by “Sister,” depicted as a completely free, live-in elder care provider. Mulaney’s character quips, “Now I don’t have to worry about Dad getting the care and attention he needs, because my sister will do it and I can get back to my life and the stuff I like to do.”
The sketch resonated deeply with audiences globally, reflecting a reality confirmed by numerous sociological studies. Research consistently indicates that daughters, on average, dedicate at least twice as much time to parental caregiving compared to sons. This gender disparity in caregiving responsibilities also correlates with men generally enjoying more leisure time. As researchers from Stanford University succinctly put it in a commentary published in JAMA Neurology, “The best long-term care insurance in our country is a conscientious daughter.”
This comedic observation aligns with rigorous academic findings. A study published in the American Sociological Review by Angelina Grigoryeva, a researcher at the University of Toronto, quantified this disparity. Her findings showed that daughters spend an average of 14 hours per month caring for parents, while sons dedicate approximately six hours. The research further revealed that sons tend to provide even less care if they have sisters, whereas daughters increase their caregiving hours when they have brothers rather than sisters. Moreover, daughters are often more inclined than sons to prioritize caregiving responsibilities even when these conflict with their professional obligations or existing childcare demands.
While Grigoryeva’s paper utilized data from 2010, she expressed confidence that the underlying dynamics have largely remained unchanged. Other data supports this, indicating that despite an increasing number of both sons and daughters engaging in caregiving as the baby boomer generation ages, women have consistently constituted around 60 percent of all caregivers. Grigoryeva noted, “I think if there will be social change, it will take decades and not years. But I hope that for the generation of our kids, men will be more involved sons, just like they’re becoming more involved fathers.”
The challenge of long-term care is a growing global concern, exacerbated by an aging population and declining fertility rates worldwide. However, the approach to this challenge varies significantly between countries. The United States, in particular, stands out for its comparatively limited federal support for family caregivers and aging adults. Unlike many other affluent nations, the U.S. federal government does not offer universal paid leave, cash benefits for caregivers, national long-term care insurance, or widely subsidized at-home or residential care options. Instead, caregiving across the lifespan is largely treated as a private matter for individual families to navigate.
The existing U.S. healthcare framework presents significant gaps in long-term care coverage. Medicare, the federal health insurance program for Americans aged 65 and older, primarily covers short-term medical needs, such as recovery from acute illness or injury. Public surveys reveal that many Americans are unaware that Medicare typically does not cover long-term daily needs, including assistance with bathing, dressing, eating, or meal preparation. Medicaid, the program for low-income individuals, does cover long-term care services, including nursing homes, home health aides, and in some cases, stipends for family caregivers. However, eligibility often requires individuals to “spend down” their savings to near poverty levels, and long waiting lists for services are common.
The private long-term care insurance market, designed to bridge these gaps, covers only about 15 percent of Americans aged 65 and older. This market is shrinking, and premiums are steadily rising, making it an inaccessible option for many. Furthermore, alternative solutions like assisted living facilities are often prohibitively expensive, and the availability of professional home health care workers is diminishing, partly due to low wages and immigration policies impacting the workforce.
Consequently, for the vast majority of U.S. families, unpaid relatives become the primary, and often sole, providers of long-term care. Research by Jonathan Gruber and Kathleen M. McGarry indicates that seven out of ten older Americans receive care exclusively from family members. If not spouses, these caregivers are predominantly daughters, particularly those with higher levels of education and income, as they are often in positions that afford more flexible work arrangements or the ability to take time off. These daughters, who bear a significant physical, emotional, and financial burden, are rarely compensated for their efforts and frequently face long-term negative impacts on their careers and overall well-being. This contrasts sharply with many other high-income countries, where older adults and their family caregivers receive more substantial governmental support. According to the World Policy Analysis Center, nearly two-thirds of high-income countries offer at least some form of paid leave for individuals caring for adult family members.
Northern European nations are often cited as global leaders in providing comprehensive support for older adults. The Netherlands, for instance, dedicates 4.1 percent of its Gross Domestic Product (GDP) to long-term care, significantly more than the 1.3 percent spent by the United States, as reported by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). Programs in the Netherlands encompass a wide array of services, including meal delivery, initiatives to combat social isolation, specialized dementia villages, and crucial respite breaks for family caregivers. While even these more generous countries still rely on family caregivers, research consistently demonstrates that nations investing more in formal care services tend to utilize less unpaid family caregiving.
Professor Kathleen M. McGarry, an economist at the University of California, Los Angeles, observed, “We have all these different countries, they have very different systems set up to deal with long-term care, but regardless of what country you look at, the majority of care is provided by family members. And everywhere it’s more likely to be daughters than sons.” Despite the recognized challenges, legislative attempts to bolster support for long-term care in the United States have faced hurdles. President Joseph R. Biden Jr.’s proposal to allocate $150 billion to expand Medicaid’s home-based care coverage and increase wages for home health aides, for example, has yet to gain sufficient political traction.
The recent “Saturday Night Live” sketch, while comedic, is seen by some experts as a positive step in raising public awareness about this often-overlooked issue. Brigid Schulte, director of the Better Life Lab at New America, commented, “I think this is an exciting step because it’s acknowledging that this is really true. We’re all kind of trapped in these roles, and then our public policies and workplace policies reinforce it, so we’re all laughing at being trapped in our own cages.”
The reasons behind daughters bearing the brunt of caregiving are multi-faceted. Societal norms often socialize women to assume caregiving roles from a young age, leading to an internalized sense of responsibility, as highlighted in the SNL sketch: “Years of internalized sexism warp Sister’s brain into thinking caretaking is her responsibility and somehow not yours.” Furthermore, employers and society at large frequently operate under the assumption that women will undertake more caregiving than men. Researchers also point to demographic factors, such as women generally outliving men, and the comfort level aging mothers may have with daughters assisting with intimate personal care. Importantly, many daughters also express a genuine desire to help their aging parents.
Looking forward, researchers suggest that meaningful change will necessitate both increased involvement from men, particularly brothers, and the implementation of comprehensive public policies designed to support older adults and their dedicated family caregivers.
Why This Matters
The increasing global population of older adults, coupled with declining birth rates, makes the provision of long-term care a critical societal challenge that impacts individuals, families, and national economies. The current reliance on unpaid family caregivers, predominantly daughters, perpetuates significant gender inequality, creating a hidden burden that affects women’s economic opportunities, mental health, and physical well-being. These caregivers often face career stagnation, reduced earnings, and diminished retirement savings, contributing to a widening wealth gap between genders.
From a broader societal perspective, the lack of robust public long-term care policies leads to inefficiencies, increased stress on healthcare systems, and potential neglect of vulnerable older adults. Without adequate support, families are forced into difficult choices, often sacrificing financial stability or personal well-being to provide essential care. The U.S. approach, which largely individualizes the responsibility for care, stands in stark contrast to many other developed nations that recognize long-term care as a collective responsibility, integrating it into national social welfare systems. This disparity highlights a crucial policy gap that affects not only the quality of life for aging citizens but also the overall productivity and equity of the workforce.
Addressing this issue through comprehensive policy changes – such as universal paid family leave, expanded public long-term care insurance, and better compensation for professional caregivers – is essential. Such reforms would not only alleviate the immense pressure on family caregivers but also stimulate economic growth by enabling more individuals, particularly women, to remain active in the workforce. Ultimately, how societies choose to care for their aging populations reflects fundamental values of compassion, equity, and intergenerational responsibility, with profound implications for future generations.

